There
has been a Skyscraper Museum in Lower Manhatttan since 1996,
although it seemed to never be in the same place. In 1999
they held an exhibit about the Empire State Building. In 2000
they held an exhibit of tall buildings, including original,
deteriorating World Trade Center and World Financial Center
models. In 2001 (in a different location) they held an exhibit
about the new Times Square towers. In 2002 and 2003 they kept
up with the times and created the information panels that
hang outside the viewing wall surrounding the World Trade
Center site. Finally in 2004 they opened up in a new permanent
home in Battery Park City in a time when everyone suddenly
cares about architecture and high rise construction.
The
museum is located on Battery Place, across the street from
Robert F. Wagner, Jr. Park and steps away from the Battery.
It is at street level in a new Ritz Carlton Hotel, on the
quiet side with no visible markers or signs. As it stands
now, it seems highly unlikely to attract anyone not specifically
looking for it, and may even deter some of those who are.
The
spaces were designed (pro bono) by Roger Duffy of Skidmore,
Owings and Merrill. The gallery features highly reflective
floors and ceiling. Columns and display cases are painted
solid white, creating an funhouse effect of endless boxy towers.
The entire space is unfortunately rather small and does not
appear to be especially flexible. It is hard to imagine exhibits
like the LMDC's in the Winter Garden being successfully displayed
in such a constricted space.
The
opening exhibit "Building a Collection" unfortunately
shows the weaknesses of the space and the collection. There
are a few artifacts from Manhattan's earlier skyscrapers and
some presentation boards and renderings of new buildings.
There are a few models hiding in the two sided display cases,
including a structural analysis of KPF's World Financial Center
in Shanghai and study models for SOM's WTC 1/Freedom Tower.
The truth is that the only reason to go to an architectural
exhibit is to see models, renderings and sections can be conveyed
just as easily in books. The layout of the space limits models
to the insides of solid columns with two glass sides. Successfully
displayed models need to be seen from multiple angles, it
is the purpose of a model. The current setup hides the models
from view and then limits your experience.
To
be fair, an exhibit called "Building a Collection"
obviously realizes that they are just starting to develop
and find their new, permanent voice. It is currently a great
time for big name architects in New York, with Renzo Piano,
Norman Foster, Frank Gehry, I.M. Pei, Enrique Norton, Jean
Nouvel and Santiago Calatrava all currently designing or building
skyscrapers in Manhattan. Hopefully the collection will grow
and stage important exhibits, but now after just seeing a
few renderings and a shiny floor it's hard to imagine feeling
like your 5 USD admission was worth it.
Skyscraper
Museum
39 Battery Place
New York City, United States
Online at www.skyscraper.org |